| |
|
|
Review: Good night, good luck, good movie
by William D. Townsend
Journalists wishing to learn from contemporary history-and there is a need for a refresher course on journalistic responsibility these days-can find the opportunity in a monograph published late last year by Western Washington University journalism professor Floyd J. McKay.

The headline in the newspaper ads for "Good Night, And Good Luck" blared: "Exclusive Engagement" at the Tivoli in University City.

Newsman Edward R. Murrow, a stickler for accuracy and the protagonist in this must-see movie, would have spiked that somewhat misleading headline.

The Tivoli did show it exclusively-for two weeks, Oct. 21 through Nov. 3. People who rushed to the Loop on Delmar could have waited for it to open elsewhere Nov. 4. It's common to place a movie in one theater before it "goes wide," so remember to take "exclusive engagement" with a grain or two of salt on your popcorn.

That said, the Tivoli is the best venue in town for a film on Murrow. Its modern seats sport drink holders, and the concession stand sells alcohol and is computerized, but the rest of the old place is clean and looks much as it did back when youngsters scampered to the show during the years Murrow and company kept the world informed.

"I used to come here when I was a boy," said a 70-something stranger to a reporter while in line for popcorn and drinks Oct. 28. "During World War II, Murrow kept our spirits up with his radio reports from Europe. He gave us the brutal facts about the bombings in London, and that made us feel lucky we weren't over there. But things could have been disasterous if the Allies hadn't won key battles in the Pacific and in Europe.


"There is no one like Murrow today," said the man, who wouldn't give his name.

Sen. Joseph R. McCarthy terrorized America in the early and mid-1950s with mostly bogus accusations and Senate hearings that ruined careers and lives. Communism and a Soviet Union with The Bomb were a one-two punch that scared Americans.

While McCarthy exploited our fear of communism, Murrow did his best to snuff out McCarthyism, like one of the 60 cigarettes he smoked every day.
In "Good Night, And Good Luck," David Strathairn gives a breathtaking, Oscar-worthy performance. From here on out, whenever anyone wants to cast a man to play Murrow on the big or small screen, Stathairn should be the guy. 
But there are enough flaws to give "Good Night, And Good Luck" a B+.

George Clooney directs the film as if it were a TV show. He jumps from scene to scene as TV does after commercials. 
He cast the wrong man (himself) as avuncular, charismatic Fred Friendly, Murrow's producer. Friendly was passionate and cut from the same cloth as Murrow and other great journalists. He produced spectacular news programs too numerous to mention. Clooney, as Fred Friendly, acts like, well, George Clooney.

But three downfalls, two of which would have been fixed easily, keep this very good movie from being spectacular.
First, Clooney selected terrific jazz classics and had more to choose from, so why did he have Dianne Reeves sing one original song, "Who's Minding the Store?" Clooney may be hoping for a Best Song Oscar, but that song wasn't sung in the 1950s, making it out of place. 
Second, Clooney should have printed a paragraph before the final credits to sum up how Murrow and McCarthy shaped their times and how the rest of their lives turned out. Both died young, McCarthy in 1956, at age 48, Murrow in 1965, at 57. 
Worse, why is the film only 90 minutes long? The world Murrow and McCarthy helped shape deserved greater attention. The performers (save for Clooney, who was OK) were exceptional and should have had more room to flesh out their characters. 
The film's best supporting actor is Ray Wise as news anchor Don Hollenbeck, a victim of the venom of a McCarthy-like columnist. The newsman's winning smile can't hide his frightened eyes. Hollenbeck was a socialist, but the film doesn't reveal it.

Despite these criticisms, see the film and make sure the kids do, too. Check local listings or wait for the DVD, etc.

One hopes the success of "Good Night, And Good Luck," leads to the production of a comprehensive TV movie or miniseries that fully explores the entire life of the founding father of modern broadcast journalism. Selecting the star should be a snap. 
William D. Townsend is a freelance writer, formerly in PR for SBC Yellow Pages and a reporter and editor for the St. Louis Globe-Democrat.
|
| |
|
|