Reporting failed to explain Edwards' departure
by Joe PollackWhen long-time media hosts and columnists suddenly vanish from sight, or are removed from the desks or armchairs they have made into key furnishings in our homes, a major furor follows.
So it was with Bob Edwards a few weeks ago, when National Public Radio suddenly announced he was being lifted from an almost 25-year presence in our bedrooms, bathrooms and kitchens five mornings a week. As the weekday host of "Morning Edition" on National Public Radio and KWMU in St. Louis, he was alongside while we struggled into wakefulness, shaved, showered, dressed, drank coffee.
He introduced men and women who gave us good news and bad. He interviewed a staggeringly wide variety of people, usually with admiration and curiosity, along with an unfailing civility. And, he asked these people-sports figures, authors, fishermen, musicians, politicians, historians, bird watchers and hundreds more-questions that showed he had done research, read the books, knew what he was talking about and what intelligent, penetrating questions to ask.
One of those regular segments bound me to Edwards. For many, many weeks, he gave us "Fridays with Red," a series of conversations with Red Barber. Barber was one of my greatest boyhood heroes, a bond formed while he was the radio voice of the Brooklyn Dodgers. In his later years, he visited with Edwards and talked of many things. I became less of a fan of Barber's politics and social thinking, but I revered him anyway.
I've met Edwards a couple of times but can't say that I know him. In terms of full disclosure, I will also note that I have worked for KWMU as a host and critic for more than a dozen years.
The announcement came as a surprise to me. I had thought that Edwards' show, one of radio's most popular with a listenership of more than 13 million, was cruising in high gear, satisfying listeners, potential donors and station managers. The size of his audience was up 40 percent in the last five years. The announcement of his departure was filled with management double-talk. Edwards will be "senior correspondent for NPR news ... expanding his news reporting presence across NPR programs, including 'Morning Edition.'" His "interviewing and presentation talents will continue to contribute significantly to NPR news." He "is one of NPR's most valued journalists and his work will continue to appear all over NPR programming, not just on 'Morning Edition.'"
The furor was large and immediate. Edwards fans wondered why there was a necessity to fix an unbroken, highly popular program whose numbers kept getting larger.
The St. Louis Post-Dispatch used a Washington Post story that quoted Executive VP Ken Stern calling the move "natural evolution" that "had to do with the changing needs of our listeners," and that it was "a programming decision about the right sound." Responsibility for the decision apparently lies with Jay Kernis, senior vice-president for programming and a man who worked with Edwards since the program first went on the air.
Sounds like the ultimate in management nonsense, but there are regiments of managers out there who feel that change is the only constant, that they must make changes to justify their own power, presence and salary. Whether the changes are necessary is not important, nor is any assurance that the product will be better.
Edwards responded with, "I would have loved to have stayed with 'Morning Edition.' But, it's not my candy store."
Listeners responded with more than 17,000 calls and e-mail messages of protest on the day of the announcement. Interestingly, The New York Times story the next day had a strange, almost inflammatory, headline that read, "NPR Stations Had Pushed For Change."
Then, The Times carried only one bland comment to back the headline ("it's time for an evolutionary change," said Jeff Hansen of KUOW, Seattle) while quoting other station executives around the country to the contrary. Stranger still were between-the-quotes comments from The Times about how NPR failed its listeners in the early hours of Sept. 11, that TV stations cut immediately to the attack on the World Trade Center while NPR continued "Morning Edition." Sounds like rumors leaked from someone in NPR headquarters.
The Times remained shallow in its coverage. Its reporter did not ask such questions as:
And, this is Edwards' fault? That he was in Washington during an attack on New York? That no director or producer or off-air honcho was trying to cover the attack? Or to get someone to the scene? Was Edwards supposed to leap from his chair, run from the studio and head for New York? Where were the news directors? The managing editors? The news executives of NPR? If the NPR news personnel are so incompetent, why did it win several awards for coverage once it did get going? The inquiring mind reels, and more important, The Times accepted the innuendo and the unnamed sources and did not follow up on what might have been a good story.
There have been rumors that Edwards showed more of a prima donna attitude in recent years, but no one has gone on the record to talk about it.
Kevin Klose, who lived in St. Louis as a boy and now is president of NPR, was in St. Louis during the week, and spoke to station staffers, contributors, executives of the University of Missouri-St. Louis, where the station is housed and others. He stayed close to message, praised Edwards, admitted the timing of the change may cause a problem when the spring fund drives begin around the country (and at KWMU) in mid-April.
The Post's Diane Toroian Keaggy also interviewed Klose, but the softball questions, in the question-answer format, provided no insight.
All the tempest seems to boil down to two conclusions: For whatever reason, Edwards is out as the host of "Morning Edition." NPR showed an incredible lack of taste and judgment, along with thoughtlessness and bad timing, risking the alienation of listeners and contributors by removing an extremely popular personality less than eight months before his 25th anniversary broadcast and only a couple of weeks before going into one of its money modes.
And, another interesting point is that NPR recently hired the well-regarded former editor of the Baltimore Sun, William Marimow, to the newly created position of managing editor of national news. Marimow quit his job at the Sun in protest over management tactics of the Chicago Tribune, the paper's owner. Was he in favor of the change? Did he know about it? Was he even consulted?